.svg){kind=small}
.svg){kind=small}
Optimism with Dirt on Its Boots
Optimism with Dirt on Its Boots
Commentary by Victor Perton
“What makes you optimistic?”
One answer may come from Australia’s cattle producers.
The latest Meat & Livestock Australia Beef Producer Intentions Survey found that national producer sentiment remains strong. More than six in ten producers reported a positive outlook for the beef cattle industry over the next 12 months, while only 8 per cent reported a negative outlook.
The result is worth noticing because it comes from producers making decisions about prices, seasons, feed, risk and future herd numbers.
The survey drew responses from more than 3,000 grassfed beef cattle producers across Australia. The question was not a direct optimism measure. It asked producers how they felt about the future of the beef cattle industry over the next 12 months. Even so, it is a useful optimism-adjacent measure because it captures positive expectation about the future.
And optimism is, at its heart, a belief that good things will happen and that things will work out in the end.
The results show national net sentiment at +53, unchanged from April 2025. Victoria and South Australia recorded the strongest results, both at +66. Tasmania also recorded strong sentiment at +63. These states have seen a notable lift from a year earlier, helped by improved prices, better seasonal conditions, rainfall and feed availability.
This is optimism with dirt on its boots.
It is practical, local and evidence-based. Producers can see enough signs of improvement to believe the year ahead may be better.
Yet the survey also reveals an important optimism gap.
While 61 per cent of producers are positive about the industry's outlook, only 26 per cent intend to increase their herd size. Most producers, 54 per cent, intend to keep their herd the same, while 21 per cent intend to reduce numbers.
That gap matters.
Many producers appear optimistic about the industry's future, although, at this time, due to local conditions or farm circumstances, they are not planning to expand their herd numbers.
There is also a regional optimism gap.
Victoria and South Australia sit at the top of the sentiment table. New South Wales, affected by dry conditions in some regions, sits below the national average. Queensland also recorded softer sentiment than a year earlier.
That tells us something important about optimism. It is often local. Rainfall, feed availability and seasonal conditions can matter more than national headlines. People’s expectations about the future are shaped by what they see, feel and manage every day.
There is a third gap, too: the gap between producer agency and global anxiety.
The survey found that producers who had become more negative cited fuel prices and shortages, geopolitical instability, production costs, and dry conditions. In other words, producers may be confident in their own skills, sector, and local opportunities while remaining wary of wider forces beyond their control.
That pattern recurs in optimism research. People are often more optimistic about what is close, familiar and influenceable than they are about distant systems, national politics or the wider world.
For Australia, this is a useful reminder.
A good country is built by people who keep acting despite uncertainty. Farmers, graziers, small business owners and regional communities often practise a highly disciplined form of optimism. They watch the skies, read the markets, manage risk and still make decisions for the future.
The Australian cattle industry has long shown that quality. Producers operate amid droughts, floods, market shifts, biosecurity risks and global volatility. Yet many continue to adapt, invest and build.
The survey shows layered optimism. Sector confidence is strong. Regional confidence varies. Expansion confidence is more cautious. Global anxiety remains real.
That is what realistic optimism often looks like.
It faces the facts. It sees the risks. It notices improvement. It acts where action is possible.
The future is never certain.
Yet across Australia, many cattle producers are still looking ahead with confidence, discipline and practical hope.
Thanks to Emiliano Diaz, MLA Senior Market Information Analyst.
.png)
.png)
.png)
Keep up to date with the latest from Centre for Optimism
We appreciate any contribution you can make to help us spread optimism with the world
.svg)
.svg)
