Why is Australian Productivity Growth So Low? The Fog of Pessimism?

Australian policymakers are grappling with an economic challenge - a persistent stagnation in productivity growth while there are increasing demands for real wage increases. 

"The reasons for this are not well understood," says Dr Philip Lowe, Governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia. 

The fact that Australians are often told they are 'doing it hard' adds a layer of complexity to this conundrum. 

Australians enjoy a high standard of living, with healthy growth in real incomes over the past five decades.

However, productivity growth has slowed considerably in the past decade, falling to its lowest rate since the 1970s. This trend mirrors a global phenomenon, as most advanced economies have recently experienced a significant and widespread deceleration in productivity growth.

As Chuck Anderson shared with us, "When employees are positive, they tend to be more productive, focused and motivated. They are more likely to take ownership of their work, meet deadlines and deliver quality outcomes."

So is a wave of pessimism reducing engagement with work, sabotaging change programs and the adoption of new technology? 

There's a tsunami of pessimism sweeping the globe, according to Umair Haque in his thought-provoking article, "Why the World Is So Pessimistic: How Disconnection — And Misconnection — Are Driving Our Civilization Crazy." This worldwide pessimism is evident across many aspects of society. In America, around 80% of people don't believe their kids will have a better life, and a similar sentiment prevails in Europe. This pessimism stems from a widespread loss of belief in key institutions and values. From religions plunging into fundamentalism to a surge in nationalism, there is a global trend of people desperately searching for something to believe in. This sentiment is echoed in contemporary studies, such as the Edelman Trust Barometer for 2023, which showed that only four in 10 respondents predicted they and their families would be "better off" in five years, marking a dramatic 10-point reduction from last year.

The potential impact of pessimism on engagement with work, change programs, and adopting new technology becomes a pressing concern. The negative mindset accompanying pessimism can hinder productivity growth by dampening enthusiasm, stifling innovation, and impeding organizational adaptability. 

Ignoring the potential correlation between the rising "stress" and "burnout" claims in the Australian workers' compensation systems and productivity stagnation is problematic. This phenomenon might indicate a broader cultural malaise affecting a portion of the working population, and its contribution to the productivity issue warrants further investigation.

Furthermore, the slowdown in productivity growth may be further exacerbated by the challenges faced by the Australian youth. The "Are The Kids OK?" study by Dr Quentin Maire, Nadishka Weerasuriya, and Associate Professor Jenny Chesters from the University of Melbourne revealed pervasive pessimism among Australian students. Fewer than half felt optimistic about Australia's future, with just one in six confident about the world's future. Moreover, this sense of pessimism was echoed by more than half of the surveyed students, suggesting a widespread concern about the fate of their generation.

Addressing Australia's productivity stagnation involves a multifaceted approach. It requires addressing the underlying factors contributing to pessimism and disengagement and implementing strategies to enhance productivity and foster a positive work environment. 

Comprehensive efforts must foster a more positive work environment, enhance work-life balance, and promote mental health and resilience. This includes providing resources for stress management, creating supportive organizational cultures, and prioritizing employee well-being.

Furthermore, addressing structural impediments to productivity growth is essential. This includes reviewing tax structures, energy policies, and workplace regulations. The current tax system discourages business investment and development, while the costly transition to renewable energy sources impedes businesses' capital input. Stringent workplace regulations have also dampened flexibility and adaptability in the labour force, affecting labour productivity.

To overcome these challenges, it's crucial for policymakers to shift their focus from short-term regulatory changes to long-term trends and structural reforms. Former Productivity Commissioner Gary Banks has emphasized the importance of implementing the recommendations outlined in the Productivity Commission's Advancing Prosperity report. These recommendations provide a blueprint for lifting living standards through improving education and skills development, encouraging innovation and entrepreneurship, and enhancing infrastructure investment.

Additionally, harnessing the potential of science, technology, and innovation is essential to drive productivity growth. Advances in digital technology, artificial intelligence, and automation present opportunities for optimizing processes, improving efficiency, and enabling new forms of production. However, realizing these benefits requires investment in research and development, digital infrastructure, and upskilling the workforce to adapt to technological advancements.

There is hope for a potential pick-up in productivity growth. Dr Lowe suggests that the post-pandemic era could witness improvements driven by advances in science and technology, public policy reforms, and more efficient service delivery methods. The acceleration of technology adoption during the pandemic, such as remote work and online commerce, has the potential to spur productivity gains in the long run. However, uncertainties remain, and navigating the post-pandemic landscape with a clear understanding of the challenges and opportunities is essential.

In conclusion, the fog of pessimism, structural impediments, and cultural malaise pose significant challenges to Australian productivity growth. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach encompassing fostering a positive work environment, addressing structural barriers, promoting technological advancements, and implementing long-term reforms. 

Australia can overcome productivity stagnation and unlock its full economic potential by cultivating a more optimistic mindset, investing in human capital, and embracing innovation. Through such efforts, Australia can build an even more prosperous future for its people and the region's people and improve our global competitiveness.

Ask yourself, what makes you optimistic?

Worth Doing: Our 5-Minute Survey on "What makes you Optimistic?"

Keep up to date with the latest from Centre for Optimism

We appreciate any contribution you can make to help us spread optimism with the world
Give Today

Connect With Us

We love to connect with everyone who is ready to open up and share their optimisim.