.svg){kind=small}
.svg){kind=small}
Optimism is a Better Tool than Hope: Rabbi Jeremy Rosen
Optimism is a Better Tool than Hope: Rabbi Jeremy Rosen
In a recent reflection on Yom Kippur, Rabbi Jeremy Rosen made a compelling case for the value of optimism over hope. He emphasised that optimism is more than a passive wish for better outcomes—it is an active force driving action and confidence. As he explained, "I prefer trust and optimism to hope. Hope can be used in many different ways to express feelings but without necessary actions or consequences."
According to Rabbi Rosen, hope often remains in the realm of possibility but does not necessarily push us to act. He illustrated this point by highlighting how people use hope in trivial contexts, such as, "I hope to win the lottery," or in more significant but passive wishes, like, "I hope my child does well in school." These examples demonstrate hope's tendency to focus on uncertain possibilities, offering little empowerment. "Hope can be ephemeral. It can be desperate," Rabbi Rosen said, underscoring its passive nature.
In contrast, optimism, in his view, is a mindset rooted in confidence and action. It requires conviction and a belief that things will work out because we will make them work out. "Optimism... gives one confidence, a way to go forward that requires action or at least self-persuasion and conviction," he explained. By suggesting optimism is "deeper and more complex" than hope, Rabbi Rosen highlights its transformative potential: where hope waits for things to change, optimism creates change.
This approach becomes especially crucial in moments of adversity. Reflecting on the conflict faced by Israel, Rabbi Rosen insisted that optimism is needed now more than ever: "At this moment we need optimism much more than hope. I don't want our soldiers to hope things will work out. I want them to have the optimism, the faith that they will survive and be victorious."
Rabbi Rosen's reflections align closely with the broader philosophy of The Optimism Principle, which states that optimism is the key to solving life's most pressing questions and challenges. Optimism encourages resilience and action, helping individuals and nations move forward with purpose, regardless of the uncertainty of outcomes. By focusing on what is within our control and maintaining confidence, optimism leads to proactive change, in contrast to hope, which can sometimes leave us waiting for change to happen.
Ultimately, Rabbi Rosen's message is a timely reminder of the power of an optimistic mindset in facing life's most significant challenges. "Our task is to live as best we can," he said, "and optimism is a better tool than hope. We pray for life, not death." Optimism drives us forward, helping us not only to survive but also to thrive.
My Reflections on Optimism v Hope
The Hopeful tend to be More Optimistic: The Optimistic Tend to be More Hopeful
Optimism, hope, and positivity drive us to action, while pessimism paralyses.
I suspect most people use words like positivity, optimism, and hope interchangeably. I don't believe you have to choose between them. Living with optimism, positivity, hope, faith, and belief is a recipe for a fulfilling and meaningful life. I embody these concepts and lift people in conversation, demonstrating the power of this positive synergy.
Optimism, hope, and positivity are not just pleasant emotions—they drive us forward. Where pessimism leads to paralysis, optimism and hope propel us into action. They reinforce each other, creating a powerful dynamic that fuels personal and societal transformation. As Rabbi Jeremy Rosen pointed out, optimism is active, demanding action and self-persuasion, while hope can sometimes remain passive. Together, however, they form a comprehensive approach to life, guiding us through challenges and uncertainties.
The relationship between optimism, hope, and action is one of mutual reinforcement. They do not stand alone but are interconnected and mutually supportive, amplifying each other's power. Far from being a passive state, optimism is often a catalyst for action, intertwined with hope to create a dynamic force for positive change.
The Real Battle?
While it's intriguing to debate the differences between hope and optimism, the real issue today is the fog of pessimism clouding many Western societies. Musician Michael Franti once said, "I believe the great battle that's taking place in the world isn't between left and right. It's between cynicism and optimism." His words reflect a broader truth: the urgent need to foster optimism amidst growing negativity. Optimism keeps us striving for a better life and a better world. When we lose that, we quit.
Former UK Leader of the House of Commons, Penny Mordaunt, echoed this sentiment, stating that the true political divide is not between left and right but between optimists and pessimists. She recognised that optimism is essential for pushing through tough times. Similarly, Singapore's President Tharman Shanmugaratnam emphasised the global importance of creating "bases for optimism" to navigate the long challenges ahead and ultimately emerge stronger. His words remind us that optimism is not a luxury - it is a necessity for survival and progress.
Ultimately, optimism, hope, and positivity do more than make us feel good - they compel us to act and transform the world. By embracing these interwoven forces, we can move beyond the fog of pessimism and create a better future for all.
What moments in your life have shown you the power of optimism and hope working together? How do you see them shaping your future?
.png)
.png)
.png)
Keep up to date with the latest from Centre for Optimism
We appreciate any contribution you can make to help us spread optimism with the world
.svg)
.svg)
