.svg){kind=small}
.svg){kind=small}
A Cynical Optimist?
The term "cynical optimist" bristles with tension—how can scepticism and optimism share the same mind?
Writing in The Australian, Greg Sheridan writes, "Badenoch describes herself as "a cynical optimist". The cynicism helps with the politics, the optimism helps with voters, and with life. The cynicism is well justified. As to optimism, that remains to be seen."
Can these clashing traits form a coherent outlook? The expression of cynical optimism is rare.
Definitions: Optimism and Cynicism
Optimism is the belief that good things will happen and that challenges can be overcome through effort and resilience. It is a forward-looking perspective that fosters hope and encourages action toward positive change. Optimism does not mean ignoring difficulties but confronting them confidently to achieve better outcomes.
Conversely, cynicism is the tendency to doubt people, institutions, or ideas' sincerity, motives, and effectiveness. A cynic often expects the worst and views promises of improvement with scepticism. While cynicism can serve as a protective mechanism against disappointment, it can also lead to disengagement and distrust. Philosopher Peter Sloterdijk, in Critique of Cynical Reason, argues that modern cynicism often manifests as an enlightened false consciousness—where individuals recognise societal issues yet feel powerless to effect change. Additionally, research has linked high levels of cynicism to negative health outcomes, including an increased risk of cardiovascular disease.
Other Expressions of Cynical Optimism
Cynical optimist? I don't know what question Greg asked Kemi. Was Badenoch describing a genuine balance of cynicism and optimism, or was it an offhand phrase mid-interview? It's a rare combination. Is the answer a word salad in mid-interview while distracted?
Are there other self-proclaimed cynical optimists? A quick search turns up a comedy podcast, A Cynical Optimism, a book, TRIALS AND TRIBULATIONS: The Musings of a Cynical Optimist by Prajwal Kumar Domalapalli, and a Huffington Post essay, Why I'm a Cynical Optimist, by Katherine Krauss, an 18-year-old high school senior.
Conclusion
Badenoch's "cynical optimist" label fascinates but falters under scrutiny. Her political cynicism distrusts systems, and her optimism lifts people—yet these forces pull apart. Optimism propels action; cynicism hesitates. One builds the other doubts. Krauss and others echo this split, but it's no harmony—it's a tug-of-war. Badenoch may navigate both, but they don't meld into one. Perhaps the phrase captures not a mindset but a struggle lived in real-time.
.png)
.png)
.png)
Keep up to date with the latest from Centre for Optimism
We appreciate any contribution you can make to help us spread optimism with the world
.svg)
.svg)
